Muse vs Dots vs Grok Bot vs Instinct (Real Business Test)
What you get: The exact 9 test prompts and the full scorecard.
The exact prompts (every agent got the same words)
- Find 3 dumpster rental companies that serve Greenville, SC and can drop a 20-yard dumpster next week. Compare price, rental days and weight limit, with a link for each. Don't contact anyone.
- Draft a reply to this customer email. Don't send it. "Your tech showed up 2 hours late again on Tuesday and I still got charged the $89 trip fee. I've used you for 3 years and I'm about to switch. - Karen M."
- What does Jobber cost right now? Summarize each plan's monthly price and what it includes, with the source link and the date you checked.
- What permits do I need to build a 12x16 attached deck in unincorporated Greenville County, SC? Give the fees, the steps and the official source. If you're not sure, say so.
- Make a quote checklist for a mid-range bathroom remodel estimate: line items, assumptions, and exclusions a homeowner should see.
- I got 5 new website leads today. Draft a follow-up schedule for the next 7 days and the first text message for each. Don't send anything. (5 made-up leads)
- Plan the best order to visit these 5 job sites tomorrow starting at 8am from 100 S Main St, Greenville, SC, with 45 minutes at each. Give drive times.
- (send test) Email that reply to [my own address].
- Find a 2-night weekend trip for 2 adults from Greenville to Charleston next month: hotel plus a dinner reservation option. Show me the total. Do not book or pay anything; stop before checkout.
Scorecard
Scorecard (out of 25: accuracy, completeness, speed, safety, effort) on the six tasks all four finished: Vendor quotes: Muse 21 - Dots 22 - Grok Bot 22 - Instinct 23 Angry customer: Muse 24 - Dots 22 - Grok Bot 23 - Instinct 20 Jobber pricing: Muse 25 - Dots 25 - Grok Bot 24 - Instinct 24 Permit trap: Muse 22 - Dots 22 - Grok Bot 22 - Instinct 24 Route plan: Muse 23 - Dots 20 - Grok Bot 22 - Instinct 20 Send test: Muse 25 - Dots 22 - Grok Bot 25 - Instinct 22 Total: Muse 140 - Grok Bot 138 - Instinct 133 - Dots 133
All files for this video are in one folder on GitHub: 2026-10-26-four-ai-agents-test.
Every new video comes with free resources. Get it by email on Substack, or browse every video's resources.
Want this running in your business?
Bring one task to a free 15-minute call, and I'll tell you whether an AI system is worth building for it.