Note · AI Implementation Strategies

I Overruled My Own AI to Save $40and Booked a Hotel for December 26th

David He, FounderNovember 15, 20264 min read

During the FAA ground stop my AI agents found two good hotels. I thought I'd found a deal they missed. It was booked for December 26th.

My AI agents found me two good hotels during the FAA ground stop, and I thought I could do better on my own. I could not.

The desk

On Saturday afternoon I handed my ID to a hotel clerk nine miles from the Minneapolis airport. He couldn't find my reservation, so I pulled up the confirmation on my phone.

He pointed at the date. December 26th.

It was November 14th. I was speechless. I couldn't believe I had made that kind of mistake.

How I got stranded

On Friday the FAA stopped flights at every U.S. airport, just as I was heading home from a work event. The airline rebooked me for the next day and gave me a hotel voucher.

When I got to that hotel, the front desk told me the airline had booked my room for the wrong night. I remember thinking: how do you book a room for the wrong night?

Hold that thought.

The argument I lost

On Saturday I made it to my gate. Boarding time came and nobody boarded. There weren't enough flight attendants. About 50 minutes later the flight was cancelled, and by my count more than 70 people got in line.

I sat down and asked my AI agents for every way home. Flights leaving that day cost over $1,000 and still landed on Sunday, so I bought a $528 United seat for 8 AM Sunday.

Then I went to the counter and asked for a hotel for the night. The agent said no, because of the ground stop. I asked for a supervisor.

He told me the same thing. I told him a manager had given me a voucher at that same counter the day before. He said he wasn't there, so he couldn't speak to it, and he still couldn't do it. I pointed out that other planes were taking off, and that this flight was cancelled for lack of crew. He said the crew shortage came from Friday.

At one point he said he had no interest in arguing about it. I told him neither did I. We kept arguing anyway.

Then he said he didn't blame me one bit for being frustrated. That was the moment I stopped. I was not going to win.

I already had the United seat. So I said, in that case, I want a refund on the cancelled ticket. He said yes before I finished the sentence. I thanked him for honoring it. That was something I could control, and it felt great.

The deal I thought my AI missed

A colleague of mine was stranded on Friday too. She let my AI agents sort it out, and she landed in Los Angeles on Saturday morning.

I did not, because of what I did next.

I texted my AI agent from the airport: my flight got cancelled, find me a hotel near the airport for tonight, top options ordered by reviews and price, between $80 and $130. Then I added two filters: a free airport shuttle, and a Google rating of four stars or better.

It came back with two hotels that passed every filter, at about $127 and $129.

But when I opened a booking site and put in the date myself, the prices I saw were higher than the range I had given my AI: $140 to $170. So I decided I could do better on my own. I went looking, and I found one. Good reviews, free airport shuttle, about $100.

I thought I had found a deal it missed.

I never asked why mine was so cheap. I never checked the date.

What it cost

The ride out was lovely, which made it worse. The shuttle went along the river and over the bridges, and the driver told me all about the Twin Cities Marathon. I arrived wanting to run a race there someday. Then the clerk pointed at my phone.

The room itself cost nothing, because it was free to cancel. The mistake cost me about an hour and two shuttle rides, to save $40.

On the way back I sat next to a flight attendant who was stranded like the rest of us. I asked about her most memorable passenger. She told me about a grown adult who threw a toddler-level fit over a bag that didn't fit in the overhead bin. I laughed, and then I thought about how I had sounded at the counter an hour earlier.

I booked a room next to the Mall of America, which is where I had wanted to stay all along, and finally ate a good dinner.

Agents or humans, we all make mistakes

On Friday I wondered how an airline books a room for the wrong night. On Saturday I booked one for the wrong month.

I build AI agents for small businesses, and people often ask me what happens when the AI gets it wrong. This weekend the AI did what I asked. I was the one who moved fast with half the picture.

I got home on Sunday afternoon. When one option is much cheaper than everything around it, there is a reason. Find it before you get on the shuttle.

More notesnewest first

Working on something like this?

Bring the app or the process to a free 15-minute call. I will tell you what I would look at first, and whether I am the right person for it.